A leader turns to the one Black woman in the room and says, gently, "What do you think we should do about this?"
It sounds like inclusion. It sounds like listening. It's often the opposite.
What's actually happening is that the person with the least power to change the system is being asked to design the fix for a problem she didn't create and has already spent years absorbing the cost of. She's being handed the labour on top of the harm.
I've watched this happen in classrooms, boardrooms, and staff meetings more times than I can count, always dressed up as collaboration. "Let's co-create the solution with them." It's a good instinct pointed in the wrong direction, because co-creation only works when everyone in the room has something like equal standing. When it's really "we don't know what's wrong, so you tell us," it isn't partnership. It's outsourcing.
What the research says
Catalyst's Emotional Tax research, which surveyed over three thousand employees from marginalised backgrounds across five countries, found that the majority are already in a state of constant vigilance at work, watching for bias, bracing for it, managing how they show up so it doesn't land on them. That vigilance is exhausting on its own, before anyone has asked for anything else. Layering a request to now go and fix the culture on top of that isn't a small ask. It's a second job, unpaid and usually unacknowledged.
This pattern has a name in academic and workplace research: the minority tax, sometimes called cultural taxation. It was first documented in academic medicine, where studies have repeatedly shown that staff from underrepresented backgrounds are disproportionately expected to sit on diversity committees, mentor other minoritised staff, and represent their group in institutional conversations, on top of their actual job, and often without it counting toward promotion or workload. The pattern isn't unique to medicine or to academia. It shows up anywhere an organisation has a gap and reaches for the nearest person who embodies it, rather than the person with the authority to close it.
Kenji Yoshino's book Covering describes a related cost: the ongoing labour of managing how much of your identity to bring into a room, calibrated constantly against how safe that room actually is. Being asked to also solve the room's problems, in real time, in front of the people who created them, adds a demand most of us would never think to ask of anyone else in the building.
And Audre Lorde put it more bluntly forty years ago: those most harmed by a system are rarely the ones with the tools to dismantle it, precisely because the system was never built to hand them those tools in the first place.
What good co-creation actually looks like
None of this means don't listen. It means separate listening from delegating. Ask people about their experience because their experience is real data. Don't ask them to also produce the analysis, design the intervention, and carry the emotional weight of presenting it back to the very people who benefit from things staying the same.
The fix sits with whoever holds the budget, the authority, and the power to change a policy. Their job is to go and do something with what they've heard, not to hand the pen back to the person who just told them what's wrong.
Further reading
Catalyst, Emotional Tax and Work Teams: A View From Five Countries (2022)
Kenji Yoshino, Covering: The Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights (Random House, 2006)
Ruchika Tulshyan, Inclusion on Purpose (MIT Press, 2022)
Audre Lorde, "The Master's Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master's House" (1984)